November 17th , 2026            Len’s Political Note #855 Chris Van Hollen v  Chuck Schumer

 Leadership Selection

Chuck Schumer.         Chris Van Hollen

Prosperity brings complications.  By the time the last votes have been counted, the US Senate will have shifted from Democrats and allies: 47 Republicans 53 to. Democrats and allies 56 Republicans 44.

It is possible that fifty-five of those fifty-six US Senators think they can oppose Donald Trump’s party in the US Senate and Donald Trump himself better than the fellow who had been leading the Democratic minority.   A few of them may be right.  But the consequence of overturning the existing leadership can be serious.

We watched the House Republicans during the last two sessions of Congress.  They entered 2022 with Kevin McCarthy of California as their leader and, as it works, the House Speaker.  They will leave 2026 with Mike Johnson of Louisiana no longer the Speaker.  In 2022, the House Republicans helped gift the Democrats with one of the largest party majorities in American history.  They have already elected their next Speaker – the odious Jim Jordon of Ohio.

Replacing Chuck Schumer with Chris Van Hollen would not necessarily lead to a massive failure of the Democrats in the Senate.  But replacing the leader of the party when it is not necessary is destabilizing.  A destabilized party is more likely to fail.  The House Republicans biggest failure was their unwillingness or inability to keep the Republican President of the United States in check.  They acquiesced to every Presidential initiative including those which led to higher prices for food, housing, and fossil fuel.  They never challenged, let alone checked, the corruption that Donald Trump was overseeing.

With or without a change in leadership in the election scheduled to take place in the Senate on December 1, Senate Democrats will make mistakes. Let’s look at the two prospective leaders and contemplate the mistakes they might make. And their prospective successes.

Chris Van Hollen

Chris Van Hollen took his high school junior year in America.  Now sixty-seven years old, he was born in Karachi where his father was a foreign service officer.  Eventually his dad became a deputy assistant secretary of state and the ambassador to Sri Lanka.  His mother worked for the CIA.  Eventually, she led the intelligence bureau for South Asia.

Except for his year at the Middlesex School in Concord, Massachusetts, Chris Hollen’s high school was the Kodaikanai International School in India.  He earned his BA at Swarthmore, his Master’s in Public Policy from the Kennedy School at Harvard, and his JD from Georgetown.  He became a staffer for a Republican Senator from Maryland, for the Senate Committee on Foreign Relations (in 1987, the year that he married Katherine Wilkens who also got a degree from the Kennedy School), and then for the Democratic Governor of Maryland.  From 1991 to 2003, Chris Van Hollen served in the Maryland House of Delegates and the State Senate.  During that time, he was part of successful efforts to increase the tobacco tax, to prohibit drilling for oil in Chesapeake Bay, to mandate trigger locks for guns, and to raise education spending.

Chris Van Hollen was elected to the US House of Representatives in 2002.  The District leaned Democratic, but its long-time representative was a Republican.  Post 2000 US Census redistricting made the district more Democratic, though not a certainty.  Chris Van Hoollen defeated Delegate Mark Kennedy Shriver by 3 points in the primary and the Republican incumbent by 3 ½ in the general election.  Chris Van Hollen did not have another close election.

In Congress, Chris Van Hollen was a dutiful advocate for federal employees, many of whom lived in his district, of federal support and leadership in education, and a critic of the Bush administration’s support of Israel’s bombing campaign in Lebanon.  He demonstrated his disregard for seniority in pressing successfully, in the interest of appointing the better Congressman, for skipping a seniority step and making Sander Levin Chair of the Ways and Means Committee.  He made allies – sharing views with colleague Adam Schiff and serving as a mock debate opponent for Vice President Joe Biden.

In 2016, he ran for the Senate, defeating Congresswoman Donna Edwards in the Democratic primary by 15 points and his Republican opponent by nearly double that amount.   In the Senate, Chris Van Hollen was frequently on the losing side of votes critical of Israel beginning with a 72-11 defeat of a Bernie Sanders’ proposal to apply human rights provisions to aid to Israel and an 82-15 defeat of a proposal to rescind the sale of $8.8 billion in munitions to Israel.  A subsequent proposal of his own to require the state department to report on Israel’s human rights’ practices on the West Bank failed 51 to 47.  Chris Van Hollen also sought an arms embargo on the United Arab Emirate which had, as he understood it, been supporting the Rapid Support Forces in the Sudan Civil War.

Domestically, Chris Van Hollen supported a variety of gun safety measures, has urged movement toward Medicare for All, opposed the military’s prohibition of transgendered soldiers, and urged higher taxes for the wealthy.

In this political fight, Chris Van Hollen has accused Chuck Schumer as being insufficiently confrontational with the Trump administration, too cautious in his approach, not urgent enough in acting against (by stopping the funding of) the Iran War, for being wrong-headed in his maintenance of the US’s traditional support of Israel, for being in the pocket of Wall Street (he was once known as the Senator from Wall Street), AIPAC, and the crypto industry, for being insufficiently pro-labor and opposing bringing pro-labor issues to the floor, and for being, at 76, too old to lead.

Chuck Schumer

Chuck Schumer knows he has Joe and Eileen Bailey on his side.  Chuck Schumer thought the couple up.  They live on Long Island and appear to be conservative Democrats.  Chuck Schumer considers what he imagines to be their views on difficult political decisions and may have baked their views into his ordinary thinking.

Chuck Schumer graduated as valedictorian of James Madison High School.  Other James Madison graduates who have distinguished themselves in the public sector are Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg and two other Senators who made up a trio of alumni in the Senate at the same time – Bernie Sanders of Vermont and Republican Norm Coleman of Minnesota.  Graduates who earned Nobel Prizes include two in Economics, three in physics, and two in medicine.

Only the Bronx High School of Science and Lycee le Grand in Paris have more graduates who have earned Nobel Prizes. Perhaps Donald Trump would have had a better chance of earning a Nobel Prize if his parents had sent him to James Madison rather than military school.

From Brooklyn, Chuck Schumer went on to Harvard where he graduated in 1971 Magna and Phi Beta Kappa.  He stayed in Cambridge and got his JD from Harvard in 1974.  That same year, he was elected to the New York Assembly to replace Steve Solarz who was elected to Congress.  In 1980, the same year he married Iris Weinshall, Chuck Schumer ran successfully for the House himself, to replace Congresswoman Elizabeth Holtzman who the Democrats nominated to attempt to replace Republican Senator Jacob Javitz.  In the House, Chuck Schumer led an effort to pass the Religious Freedom Restoration Act in response to a Supreme Court decision emphasizing neutrality among religions.  He was also on Bill Clinton’s defense team after his impeachment.

In 1998, Chuck Schumer ran for the Senate and ousted incumbent Republican Al D’Amato after defeating former Congresswoman and former Vice Presidential nominee Geraldine Ferraro in the primary.  When Hillary Clinton lost the 2016 election, Chuck Schumer explained the Democrats lacked a strong economic message and needed to address that by making college more affordable and changing trade laws to make life more affordable.  He moved relatively quickly into a leadership role alongside Harry Reid.  When Reid retired in 2016, Chuck Schumer became Minority Leader.  Since then, he has been either the Majority or Minority Leader of the Democrats in the Senate.

Not every deal he has made with Trump is easily explained.  His initial willingness and then rejection of a House passed continuing budget resolution brought little in visible benefits to the Democrats when it finally passed.  There was some satisfaction in the Republicans being blamed again for a government shutdown.

Chuck Schumer has demonstrated a preference for finding a path to supportable legislation and has had little interest in symbolic positions.  Leading the Senate Democrats, especially when in the minority and there is a Republican President is not an easy task. It is not so easy even when in the majority.  So far as we know, the Baileys approve of Chuck Schumer’s work as Leader.

Until there was a substantial Democratic majority in the Senate, no challengers appeared.  A CNN report described Chuck Schumer’s Democratic opposition as extending beyond policy difference to the personal, with questions that have not been raised before about Chuck Schumer’s integrity.  Chuck Schumer says he has the votes to win.

As Leader, either Chris Van Hollen or Chuck Schumer will make mistakes.  As best I can from his history, Chuck Schumer’s caution can lead to errors of omission.   And as best I can tell from his history Chris Van Hollen’s boldness can lead to errors of commission.

Is Van Hollen’s open contest already an error of commission? Is Schumer’s reluctance to engage in open debate an error of omission?  With this contest, has the damage already been done?

 

Robert Hubbell has urged us all to get involved.  Consider your preference.  Let your Democratic Senators know who you think they should support. .As I have said, I am satisfied with Chuck Schumer’s leadership.  I believe that ousting him from the leadership without a good reason does harm to this new, large majority.

Let’s focus first on the making life in this country more affordable – restore Medicaid funds, restore the support for the Affordable Care Act.  End Trump’s authority to impose tariffs.  And then ensure that people vote.  Pass the John Lewis Voting Rights Act and more.  Take steps to address corruption in the Trump administration, the most important of which is probably the tax cuts for the wealthy and corporations in the Big Beautiful Bill.  Those were the equivalent of Trump’s bribe offer – but paid ahead of time without regard for the outcome – of $5,000 to every adult if the Republicans maintained control of the House and Senate.

Go ahead. Call your Senators.  Tell them how you think they should vote on December 1.